If you follow me on twitter or facebook, you know that I am very actively reading what is being written about surrogacy, egg donation, sperm donation, embryo donation and IVF in Canada and around the world, and I love to share this information with others who are interested in these topics, too. Once in a while, I come across something truly exceptional about third party reproduction in Canada that warrants more than a facebook or twitter post. Tonight I came across a blog that is a must read for anyone who is contemplating surrogacy in Canada (either as a gestational carrier or an intended parent). The blog, called A Tale of Two Mothers - Journey through Canadian Surrogacy, is written from both the perspective of the gestational carrier, and the perspective of the intended mother. It highlights some of the emotional ups and downs and concerns from both points of view. This blog offers us a rare glimpse into these two women's thoughts, emotions, struggles and relationships. How privileged we are to be offered this insight!
0 Comments
6/29/2012 0 Comments In Honour of Pride Week - Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ARTs) and the LGBTQ communityFor me, PRIDE is a time of hope and celebration, and I think it is apropos that we recognize just how far we have come as a society in helping all people who want children build their families in various ways, including through assisted reproductive technologies (ARTs). I often mention that, in my opinion, the Assisted Human Reproduction Act starts out with a bang that is truly something to be proud of (unfortunately it fizzles out from there). Specifically, the Act states that, s. 2 The Parliament of Canada recognizes and declares that… (e) persons who seek to undergo assisted reproduction procedures must not be discriminated against, including on the basis of their sexual orientation or marital status. While ARTs are often lauded for their success in helping people with infertility, they are just as useful, necessary and laudable for members of the LGBT community who do not suffer from infertility. Gay men in particular benefit from accessible ARTs with an emphasis on the T for technology; donor insemination has long been a self-help remedy, but there is no corresponding self-help remedy for gestational surrogacy. Although there is much to celebrate (and there really is – so many beautiful families would not have been possible without ARTS), it’s imperative that we learn how to make section 2(e) of the AHRA more than just an ideal but a reality. To that end, I want to share with you the hands-down best presentation regarding ARTs that I have been to all year, which hopefully will obain the funding to be presented repeatedly throughout Ontario: Reframing Assisted Human Reproduction: A forum theatre workshop about LGBTQ people’s experiences with AHR services The workshop is based on interviews conducted with 66 LGBTQ people across Ontario who have used, considered using, and/or avoided using AHR to have genetically related children. Some of the worst experiences of the interviewees are portrayed for the audience (the performance is candid that it is reflective of the worst-case scenarios and doesn’t reflect any of the positive experiences of the LGBTQ community accessing ART services in Ontario). I have to admit, I had my doubts about a performanced based workshop, but it was incredibly effective. As far as we have come with people of the LGBTQ community having access to ARTs, the experiences as performed in the workshop were shocking, eye-opening and traumatic. From the things that we can easily remedy to be more sensitive, such as offering genderless bathrooms, to the way consent forms are drafted making assumptions as to gender and sexuality, this presentation highlighted practical ways in which we can make ART services truly accessible to the LGBTQ community. For more information, please contact Lesley Tarasoff Phone: 416-535-8501 x 7386 Email: [email protected] or see http://www.lgbtqhealth.ca/
4/5/2012 2 Comments Dear Margaret, it's me, SaraDear Margaret,
It's me, Sara. Like many others, I'm a fan. Loved Alias Grace, The Robber Bride. Enjoyed your poetry. Above all, though, I love The Handmaid's Tale. I remember the first time I read The Handmaid's Tale. I was so affected by the book - the characters, yes, but even more so the ideas, the possibilities, how a society can go so very, very wrong. I'm certain that I have never looked at butter the same way. Since then, I would guess that I have read it at least five more times and it undoubtedly was influential on my chosen and beloved career path - fertility law. As you are no doubt aware, your book is (dis)credited as the basis upon which the Baird Report and the subsequent Asssisted Human Reproduction Act were written. It is therefore in your name that, in ostensibly trying to protect women from being exploited for their reproductive capabilities as were the women in Gilead, the Assisted Human Reproduction Act prohibits paying a surrogate for her services, an egg donor for donating her eggs, or a person for arranging the services of a surrogate mother, whatever that means (including, ideally, a person with specialized training in the relationships between gestational carriers and intended parents). Now, when I read The Handmaid's Tale, I don't see it as a call for the state to protect women from being exploited; rather, I see it as a message about the potential dangers inherent when a state imposes its ethical and moral views on its people in the name of protecting them - which, in my opinion, is exactly what the Assisted Human Reproduction Act has done. So, dear Ms. Atwood, you are so involved with local and national politics and are undoubtedly one of the most influential Canadians of our time - could you please lend your voice to this issue, too? Women are capable of and should be entitled to make decisions about their bodies, including being paid to donate their ova to others who need them to build their family, or being paid to act as a gestational carrier to people who cannot build their family without their help. If women obtain medical advice, independent legal advice and psychological counselling and choose to engage in surrogacy or egg donation, why should the state protect them from themselves when they do not need or want protecting? 3/29/2012 0 Comments The biggest news in fertility law in Canada: Assisted Human Reproduction Canada scrapped - what does this mean for fertility law in Canada?The federal government of Canada announced its budget today. Noticeably absent is any funding for Assisted Human Reproduction Canada (AHRC), the federal corporate body enacted to implement the Assisted Human Reproduction Act and its regulations. By scrapping the AHRC, Canada will save nearly $10 million per year (see Health care a target in Tories’ deficit reduction plan).
In December 2010, the Supreme Court of Canada found that many aspects of the assisted reproductive technologies (ARTs) were within provincial jurisdiction as they are health, and not criminal, matters. Accordingly, much of the Assisted Human Reproduction Act was found to be unconstitutional (see the Supreme Court of Canada decision here). However, sections 5 through 9 (among others) remain. Notably, sections 6 (which prohibits the payment of a surrogate mother) and 7 (which prohibits the payment for eggs or sperm from a donor or a person acting on behalf of a donor) remain in force. Eliminating the AHRC does not legalize any of the prohibitions in sections 5 through 9. However, it will undoubtedly affect the enforcement of the AHRA, and further demonstrates just how unrealistic and unworkable the current state of fertility law in Canada really is. Let's hope that the federal government scraps the AHRA completely instead of holding on to a poorly constructed piece of legislation and flogging a dead horse. As stated by Justices LeBel and Deschamps at para 251 of the SCC Reference re Assisted Human Reproduction Act, "...Parliament, in adopting the Baird Report’s recommendation on controlled activities, intended to establish national standards for assisted human reproduction. The purpose was not, therefore, to protect those who might resort to assisted human reproduction on the basis that it was inherently harmful. Assisted human reproduction was not then, nor is it now, an evil needing to be suppressed. In fact, it is a burgeoning field of medical practice and research that, as Parliament mentions in s. 2 of the AHR Act, brings benefits to many Canadians." 12/19/2011 0 Comments What is fertility law?When people hear what I do for a living, they inevitably ask me - "what is fertility law?"
I decided to use my first blog post to explain what fertility law is. Fertility law is the developing area of law dealing with the legal issues regarding building families through assisted reproductive technologies (otherwise known as ARTs). Fertility lawyers are used in a number of situations, but are most often required when a person or a couple is using the help of a third party, such as an egg donor, sperm donor, embryo donor and/or a surrogate, to build their family. Fertility lawyers provide legal advice and guidance about the legal framework relevant to the use of third party assisted reproductive technologies, and obtaining legal parentage for the children born through these technologies. In addition, fertility lawyers provide advice to fertility clinics, sperm banks, cryobanks and other members of the fertilitiy industry. For a very brief explanation of the current framework for fertility law in Canada, click here. Most often, the next question I am asked is, "I didn't realize there was such a thing as fertility law. Is there a need for that niche?" My answer is a resounding YES! Although terms like I.V.F., ICSI, IUI, and surrogate may no longer be completely foreign to the general public, the legal issues surrounding them continue to be. With respect to surrogacy arrangements, there are relevant statutes and various provincial caselaw of which a lawyer needs to be aware, especially as the law relates to obtaining legal parenthood. Further, the issues related to the use of surrogacy as a method of ART are far-reaching in consequence and many may be overlooked without consulting a fertility lawyer. For example, a surrogacy agreement should answer questions such as, what happens if the intended parents separate prior to the baby being born? Can the surrogate mother put pictures of the baby on Facebook or other social media sites? Not only is it wise to enter into a surrogacy agreement prior to the embryo transfer (and, in some provinces, necessary), but through the process of drafting the surrogacy agreement, the parties have an opportunity to work out many of the potential issues that could present themselves months down the road. Most fertility clinics require that the intended parents and surrogate enter into a legal surrogacy arrangement prior to performing the embryo transfer. When in the process should I contact a fertility law lawyer? As early as possible. Not only can fertility law lawyers provide you with legal advice, but they are often a great source for resources. Some fertility lawyers will provide free consultations. |
AuthorSara R. Cohen practices fertility law at Fertility Law Canada™ in Toronto, Canada with clients across the country and beyond. She loves what she does, and it shows! Archives
February 2020
CategoriesAll 2011 2012 Abortion Age Ahra Ahrc Andre Picard Anonymous Donation Asrm Assisted Human Reproduction Act Assisted Human Reproduction Canada Blair Commission Blessings Building Family Canadian Medical Association Journal Cbc Cmaj Declaration Of Parentage Discrimination Donor Insemination Donor Sperm Egg Bank Egg Donation Egg Donor Embryo Donor Embryo Selection Ethics Federal Budget Feminism Fertility Law Fertility Law Canada Frozen Eggs Frozen Sperm Gamete Gender Grateful Handmaids Tale Hope Infertility Intended Parents Isis Regional Fertility Centre Ivf J.C.M. V. A.N.A. Legal Parentage Legal Status At The Federal Level Of Assisted Human Reproduction In Canada Lgbt Margaret Atwood Ova Parliament Background Paper Pgd Pratten Pride Professor Karen Busby Property Law Repromed Semen Regulations Sex Selective Abortions Shana Tova Sperm Sperm Bank Sperm Donation Sperm Donor Supreme Court Of Canada Supreme Court Of Canada Reference Re Assisted Human Reproduction Act Surrogacy Surrogacy In Canada The World Egg Bank Three-person Ivf Warawa What Is Fertility Law |
Contact us by email at [email protected] or phone at 647.696.7189. International clients can contact us by whatsapp at 647.696.7189